5) Marouane Fellaini (Everton and Manchester United) – 37 goals
The midfielder’s ungainly style did not win him many admirers but he was a physical presence in the box for both the Toffees and the Red Devils.
Fellaini was excellent in the air and he regularly popped up with crucial headed goals, although he was never prolific, having only got into double figures in one of his 12 seasons in England.